// ELECTRIC POWER TRANSMISSION SYSTEM ENGINEERING ANALYSIS AND DESIGN // TURAN GONEN // CRC PRESS // SECOND EDITION // CHAPTER : 10 : PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT AND TRANSMISSION SYSTEM PROTECTION // EXAMPLE : 10.5 : clear ; clc ; close ; // Clear the work space and console // CALCULATIONS // For case (a) // Coordinate Values taken here are only for reference . Refer exa 10.5 T = 0:0.01:300 ; for i = 1:int(length(T)/1.1) ; po(i) = 4 ; end for i = int(length(T)/1.1):length(T) po(i) = 5 ; end for i = 1:int(length(T)/1.1) io(i) = 4 ; end for i = int(length(T)/1.1):length(T) io(i) = 3 ; end a= gca() ; subplot(2,1,1) ; // To plot 2 graph in same graphic window a.thickness = 2 ; // sets thickness of plot of points plot2d(T,po,3,'012','',[0 0 310 7]) ; plot2d(T,io,3,'012','',[0 0 310 7]) ; xtitle("Fig 10.5 (a) Zones of protection for relay R_12") ; xset('thickness',2); // sets thickness of axes xstring(25,3.8,'[]') ; xstring(45,4.2,'(1)') ; plot(45,4,'+') ; xstring(60,3.8,'[]') ; xstring(60,4.2,'B_12') ; xstring(120,3.8,'[]') ; xstring(120,4.2,'B_21') ; xstring(140,4.2,'(2)') ; plot(140,4,'+') ; xstring(155,3.8,'[]') ; xstring(155,4.2,'B_23') ; xstring(220,3.8,'[]') ; xstring(220,4.2,'B_32') ; xstring(270,5.0,'(3)') ; xstring(285,2.8,'[]') ; xstring(285,3.2,'B_35') ; xstring(285,4.8,'[]') ; xstring(285,5.2,'B_34') ; xstring(85,3.4,'TL_12') ; xstring(180,3.4,'TL_23') ; xstring(60,3,'ZONE 1') ; xstring(100,2,'ZONE 2') ; xstring(190,1,'ZONE 3') ; // For case (b) for i = 1:int(length(T)/4) ; vo(i) = 0.5; end for i = int(length(T)/4):length(T/1.7) vo(i) = 2; end for i = int(length(T)/1.7):length(T) vo(i) = 4 end for i = int(length(T)/2.14):length(T/1.35) ; // plotting Voltage values uo(i) = 0.5; end for i = int(length(T)/1.35):length(T) uo(i) = 2; end a = gca() ; a.thickness = 2 ; subplot(2,1,2) plot2d(T,vo,2,'012','',[0 0 310 7]) ; plot2d(T,uo,2,'012','',[0 0 310 7]) ; ylabel("OPERATING TIME") ; xlabel("IMPEDANCE") ; xtitle("Fig 10.5 (b) Coordination of distance relays , Operating time v/s Impedance") ; xset('thickness',2); // sets thickness of axes xstring(0.1,0.3,'T_1') ; xstring(30,0.6,'R_12') ; xstring(58,1.3,'T_2') ; xstring(100,2.0,'R_12') ; xstring(160,3.0,'T_3') ; xstring(230,4.0,'R_12') ; xstring(160,0.6,'R_23') ; xstring(260,2.1,'R_23') ; // DISPLAY RESULTS disp("EXAMPLE : 10.5 : SOLUTION :-") ; printf("\n (a) The zone of protection for relay R_12 is shown in Fig 10.5 (a) \n") ; printf("\n ZONE 1 lies b/w (1) & B_21 \n") ; printf("\n ZONE 2 lies b/w (1) & TL_23 \n") ; printf("\n ZONE 3 lies after (1) \n") ; printf("\n (b) The coordination of the distance relays R_12 & R_21 in terms of Operating time v/s Impedance is shown in Fig 10.5 (b)") ;